Choosing the right signup sheet tool can make or break your event coordination. SignUpGenius has been the industry leader since 2007, but newer alternatives like SignUpReady are gaining traction. In this detailed comparison, we'll help you decide which tool is best for your school, sports team, church, or community group.
Quick Takeaways
- ✓SignUpGenius: More templates, larger user base, but has ads on free plan
- ✓SignUpReady: Always ad-free, modern design, faster setup, lower pricing
- ✓Both offer free plans with email notifications and participant management
- ✓SignUpReady wins on mobile experience and ease of use
- ✓SignUpGenius wins on template variety and integrations
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | SignUpReady | SignUpGenius |
|---|---|---|
| Free Plan Ads | ✓ Always ad-free | Has ads |
| Interface | ✓ Modern (2024) | Classic (2008) |
| Setup Time | ✓ ~60 seconds | 2-5 minutes |
| Free QR Codes | ✓ Yes | Paid only |
| Templates | 34+ | ✓ 50+ |
| Starting Price | ✓ Free / $9/mo | Free / $11.99/mo |
| Mobile Experience | ✓ Mobile-first | Responsive |
| User Base | Growing | ✓ 96M users |
Advertising Experience
This is where the two platforms differ most dramatically.
SignUpReady
100% ad-free on all plans, including free. Your signup sheets always look professional when shared with parents, team families, or church members.
SignUpGenius
Free plan displays advertisements. Users report ads can "interfere with functionality" and make sheets "look less legit." Ad-free requires $11.99/mo plan.
Why This Matters
When you send a signup link to your group, it reflects on you. Ad-heavy pages can appear unprofessional and distract participants from the signup process.
Interface & Design
SignUpGenius launched in 2007 and while functional, its interface reflects that era. SignUpReady was built in 2024 with modern design principles.
SignUpReady Interface
- ✓Clean, modern aesthetic
- ✓Mobile-first responsive design
- ✓Intuitive navigation
- ✓Fast page loads
- ✓Minimal learning curve
SignUpGenius Interface
- •Functional but dated appearance
- •Some mobile usability issues reported
- •More options (can be overwhelming)
- •Familiar to existing users
- •More customization options
Pricing Comparison
| Plan | SignUpReady | SignUpGenius |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 (ad-free, 50 participants/sheet) | $0 (with ads, unlimited participants) |
| Ad-Free + Features | $9/month (Plus) | $11.99/month (Silver) |
| Full Features | $29/month (Pro) | $29.99/month (Gold) |
Value Analysis
SignUpReady's free plan is ad-free, making it more valuable for most users. If you need paid features, SignUpReady's Plus plan saves $2.99/month vs SignUpGenius Silver.
Feature Comparison
What Both Platforms Offer
- ✓Email confirmations to participants
- ✓Automated reminders
- ✓Multiple slots with limits
- ✓Custom slot dates and times
- ✓Calendar integration
- ✓Mobile-responsive forms
SignUpReady Exclusive Features
- ✓Free QR code generation
- ✓Always ad-free experience
- ✓One-click sheet duplication
- ✓Modern, fast interface
- ✓Simpler setup process
SignUpGenius Exclusive Features
- ✓More template options (50+)
- ✓Longer track record (since 2007)
- ✓More integrations
- ✓Volunteer hour tracking (paid)
- ✓Payment collection (paid)
Which Should You Choose?
Choose SignUpReady If You...
- ✓Want an ad-free experience (even on free plan)
- ✓Value modern, clean design
- ✓Need quick setup (under 60 seconds)
- ✓Prioritize mobile experience
- ✓Want lower pricing for premium features
- ✓Don't need payment collection or hour tracking
Choose SignUpGenius If You...
- ✓Need volunteer hour tracking
- ✓Require payment collection
- ✓Want maximum template variety
- ✓Value a longer track record
- ✓Don't mind ads on free plan
- ✓Need specific integrations
The Verdict
Both SignUpGenius and SignUpReady are capable signup sheet tools, but they serve different priorities:
SignUpGenius is the established player with more features and templates, but comes with ads on the free plan and a dated interface.
SignUpReady is the modern challenger that prioritizes user experience, offering an ad-free experience on all plans, faster setup, and better mobile design at a lower price point.
For most schools, sports teams, and community groups who want professional-looking signup sheets without paying for premium plans, SignUpReady offers better value. The ad-free free plan alone makes it worth trying.
Try SignUpReady Free
See the difference for yourself. Create your first signup sheet in 60 seconds.
Get Started Free